Tag Archives: Artificial Intelligence

Trying Out Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook, Part 1

In Part 1 of my foray into Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook, I outlined the format of the workbook and shared an abbreviated version of the Table of Contents.

The Introduction provided an overview of the development of AI, tools that we currently have available and how to make best use of this workbook.

Chapter 1 has its focus on learning a bit about the four main AI tools in use today – ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity – and a format to follow to craft effective efficient prompts for genealogical research.

I’ve used all four platforms in the past – only the free versions – and learned something interesting with the genealogy group that I teach. There were six of us, all using my house internet. I gave the exact same prompt to everyone and we shared out results. Curiously, NO TWO of us had the exact same responses – they varied slightly. However, one person had a response that wasn’t anything like what the rest of us had even though she used the exact same prompt wording.

This time around, I didn’t try giving the same prompt to the same platform more than once, and I already had a couple of favorite platforms, but I did want to see the replies from each bot to the same prompt:

Role: Professional genealogist specializing in early New Brunswick, Canada research. Task: Search the web for information about primary records pertaining to Loyalists who settled in New Brunswick, Canada before 1790. Provide details about the repositories with primary record collections and books written about Loyalists in Parrtown before 1790. Create a list of the resources, repositories and websites found.

I will state, right from the start, that Gemini is my least favorite bot and it provided the worst results – only about 2 pages of information – when the other three bots provided 4-5 pages of details.

Of the remaining three – ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity – ChatGPT was the second weakest, although I was surprised to see that only ChatGPT (5) included mentions of Black Loyalists or the New York Public Library Manuscripts Division or the New Brunswick Genealogical Society.

Yes, the focus is on New Brunswick records, but the prompt doesn’t specify only New Brunswick resources. Many Loyalists sailed to Canada from New York and there are primary records to be found there.

Aside from that, ChatpGPT 5’s font was much larger than that of Claude and perplexity plus the last page was just a summary of the items on the first 3 pages.

Let’s say I was not impressed with ChatGPT 5’s performance. On top of that, I wanted to print out hard copies of each of the responses so I could go through and compare repeated resources and those unique to one response. Apparently, to print is an upgrade on ChatGPT so I had to copy and paste into Word. Doable, but kind of a nuisance.

Claude and Perplexity both produced well-done responses and both had easy-to-use download/print buttons.

CLAUDE grouped resources by Major Repositories and Archives (University of New Brunswick, Provincial Archives of new Brunswick, Library and Archives Canada and FamilySearch collections), Primary Record Collections (Land, Military, Court and Vital Records), Specific Parrtown/Saint John Records (Key Collections and Important Documents), Published Works and Books (Only one book mentioned though, which is a big weakness here), and Special Research Notes. There were a few online links, but, for the most part, it will take a bit more digging to land on the websites. Its font size was on the big side so its 4 pages would equal about 3 1/2 compared to Perplexity’s font size.

PERPLEXITY, overall, had the most thorough response, with five pages of detailed information using the smallest font. It covered Major Repositories and Websites, Books and Major Collections on Loyalists in Parrtown Before 1790, Key Primary Record Sets and Finding Aids, Summary List of Top Resources, Historical Overview of Parrtown, Major books, Major Archival Manuscript Collections, Principal Repositories and Websites and closed with 18 source citation links.

As a retired teacher, in my mind, I graded the responses for each. Perplexity was clearly an A, Claude a B, mostly for the lack of book titles provided, ChatGPT got a C- and Gemini a D.

The remainder of Chapter 1 involved using a format for creating effective prompts, techniques for creating more advanced prompts [five steps which I will be following], ways that bots can transform information and ethical and legal considerations when using AI.

As I am completing Chapter 1, I want to say upfront because of my own personal bias, I adjusted the tools I used to get set up and ready to begin this workbook. Google Docs and Airtable are both highly recommended, but I am choosing not to use either for one simple reason. I don’t like my original work to be sitting in the cloud and much prefer to have it saved on my own computer and will be using Word and Excel instead. As stated, that’s just a personal opinion. The cloud is fine for backups, but not original work.

The Introduction and Chapter 1 practices were interesting. Since I’ve used AI tools already, I think the most useful tip I’ve learned is from the Crafting Effective Prompts section using the five detailed components for prompts.

Trying Out Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook, Introduction

Diana Elder and Nicole Elder Dyer do a fabulous job with their process called Research Like a Pro. I’ve been a fan for a long time and have all their books.

Artificial intelligence is here to stay and, while I’ve embraced much of what it can provide genealogy researchers, I will admit that I’m not a fan of AI doing my writing for me, even with me editing the product. Absolutely ZERO of my 15 years of blog posts have been written with AI.

I do love its capabilities to help with reading and indexing documents, helping develop research plans and using the various AI products as sophisticated online search engines.

However, I detest those AI-created images. I’m much rather see historical photos or no image at all unless the posts are all about using AI. Then, they are fine.

Having said that, even though I’m definitely a senior citizen, I do want to stay on top of the latest research tools and techniques so I’ve decided to try out Diana’s and Nicole’s Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook.

Instead of doing a straight book review, I am going to work on each chapter in the workbook and then write about my experience and add my thoughts.

To begin, if you aren’t familiar with Diana’s and Nicole’s work, they host Family Locket, and provide genealogy education through podcasts, courses, books and genealogy talks.

Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook is available to purchase on the website as a digital download for $39.99. I made the purchase and then printed out the workbook and put the pages in a softcover plastic notebook. This is just an aside, but for those who do want a printed copy, I love that they had downloadable images for a front and back cover, in color, which I used.

I also save paper by printing out the workbook with all odd numbered pages first, flipped the paper over in the printer, and then did all the even numbered pages. I wasn’t sure that the pages would come out in the correct order since I had to manually switch to the back side of the paper, but the workbook printed perfectly.

What sorts of activities will I be doing?

The workbook has a very detailed Table of Contents, but here are just the chapter titles:

Introduction

Chapter 1: Introduction to AI Tools for Genealogy
Chapter 2: Using AI to Formulate a Research Objective
Chapter 3: Using AI for Timeline Creation and Analysis
Chapter 4: Using AI for Citations
Chapter 5: Using AI for Locality Research
Chapter 6: Using AI in Research Planning
Chapter 7: Using AI in Research Logging
Chapter 8: Using AI in Report Writing
Chapter 9: Embracing AI in Your Genealogical Research Process

Index

Where does my own skill level fall in terms of using AI?

I’ve attended quite a few online webinars on the basics of using AI and have tried out each of the main AI products with a preference for ChatGPT. However, I have not upgraded to any paid services.

I’m proficient at using FamilySearch full-text search and have used AI to help find resources to created a locality guide, which I did by hand. AI was an afterthought because I wanted to see if it could find other websites, books, etc., that would be useful.

While I’ve used timelines often, I created them myself in Word or Excel and my research logs are usually notes I add to my genealogy software.

I’d say I’m about in the intermediate range when it comes to my AI skills – not a beginner, but most definitely not an expert user, which is why trying out the process is intriguing to me.

I also think that by committing myself to blogging about my efforts, I’m more likely to stick with the process until I complete Chapter 9.

Coming up – my experience with Chapter 1: Introduction to AI Tools for Genealogy.

ChatGPT & My Biographical Sketch

A while back, another blogger tried out Chat GPT’s capability to write out a biographical sketch of himself and commented how (scarily) well AI did so, out of curiosity, I thought I would try it myself.

My prompt was to write a biographical sketch about myself and provided my maiden and married surnames. I thought AI might also do a good job for me since I’ve written a lot about my life growing up and as a genealogist. WRONG!

Here is what appeared:

First, this is a bulleted list, which would be easy enough to correct if the details were right, but they aren’t, by a long shot.

What’s wrong?

  1. Birth date
  2. I have absolutely no ability to move to music, aka dancing.
  3. I didn’t write the above mentioned books.
  4. I don’t live alone.
  5. I don’t find solace in photography.
  6. There was no Shakespeare fiasco.
  7. Most importantly, I didn’t pass away five years ago!!!
  8. With all the inaccuracies, the summary is wrong, too.

About the only correct items are where I went to high school and my Blogging Ventures.

For those who are enamored of AI-generated writing, fiction is fine, but if you are expecting AI to create historically accurate articles about real people, living or dead, be sure to proofread carefully before sharing or AI’s lies will reproduce faster than those crazy online trees.