All posts by Linda Stufflebean

Linda is a retired special education teacher, who is also a 35+ year genealogy addict.

Descendants of Isaac & Catherine (Johnson) Riddle, Cumberland County, KY, Part 5 – Christianna, Eliza and Jane

Christianna, Eliza and Jane were the sixth, seventh and eighth children born to Isaac and Catherine (Johnson) Riddle.

Christianna, who went by Annie, was born 10 September 1883 in Cumberland County, Kentucky. She lived a long life, passing away n 23 January 1923 in Overton County, Tennessee.

Annie married twice. Her first husband was Elijah York and they married about 15 September 1850. Annie was enumerated twice in 1850. On 13 September, she was a Riddle in her parent’s home. On the 15th of September she was the apparent newlywed wife of Elijah. Elijah died quite young as Annie married (2) Joseph Michael Nation, known as Mike, about 1856.

Annie reported having given birth to 15 children in the 1900 census, but only 13 in the 1910 census with about five children having died before that time.

However, only eleven of her children can be identified.

Children: (York)

1. Isaac York, born c1851, Fentress County, Tennessee; married Margaret (MNU),  November 1869 per the 1870 census taker. She was born c1855. They haven’t been found after the 1870 census.
2. Catherine York, born c1853, Fentress County, Tennessee; married Francis Marion Wallace, 3 December 1875, Clinton County, Kentucky. They had one son and one daughter in 1880, but the family hasn’t been found in later records. The name might be Wallace, but the Willis family was also in Cumberland County, Kentucky, where they were living in 1880.
3. Greenville F., born c1856, Fentress County, Tennessee; died 11 May 1916, Garrard County, Kentucky; married Susan Ellen Brewster, 31 January 1874, Wayne County, Kentucky. They were the parents of ten children, with eight living in 1910.

Children: (Nation)

  1. Nancy Ann, born 20 March 1858, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 31 August 1915, Verden, Grady County, Oklahoma; married James Burk, c1882, probably Tennessee. He was born c1852; died 1941.
  2. Henry Jackson, born 7 May 1860, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 14 November 1936, Anadarko, Caddo County, Oklahoma; married (1) Lucinda Tranbarger, 28 August 1890, Overton County, Tennessee (2) Martelia Claiborne, 19 July 1894, Overton County, Tennessee. Lucinda was born c1875; died 1893. Martelia was born c1875; died 1962.
  3. Joseph, born c1863, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 11 July 1925, probably Overton County, Tennessee; unmarried.
  4. John Wesley, born 19 August 1866, Tennessee; died 26 September 1943, Putnam County, Tennessee; married Anna Belle Robins, 27 January 1887, Overton County, Tennessee. She was born c1867; died 1950.
  5. Rosetta, born September 1869, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 12 May 1892, probably Overton County, Tennessee; married Sylvester Columbus Robins, 27 January 1887, Overton County, Tennessee. (Yes, brother and sister married a brother and sister and had a double wedding.) He was born c1863; died 1922.
  6. Thomas Nathan, born 12 March 1871, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 11 April 1916, Overton County, Tennessee; married Mary Jane Mathis, 12 May 1892, Overton County, Tennessee. She was born c1864; died 1926.
  7. Clayton Columbus, born 18 September 1872, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died 30 June 1922, Granite, Greer County, Oklahoma; married Matilda Jane Dulworth, 20 June 1896, Clay County, Tennessee. She was born c1869; died 1931.
  8. Alice, born c1875, Cumberland County, Kentucky; died c1904-1910, probably Overton County, Tennessee; married Matthew Winburn Matthews, 10 January 1891, Overton County, Tennessee. He was born 4 December 1862; died 9 August 1944, Robertson County, Tennessee. Alice’s last child was born c1904. She died sometime between that birth and the 1910 census.

The full family sketch of Annie (Riddle) Nation was previously published in 2017.

The remainder of this post will be brief as little is known about either Eliza or Jane.

Eliza Riddle was born c1837 in Cumberland County, Kentucky, the last Riddle child to be born there before the move to Fentress County, Tennessee. She is last found at home in 1850. Family lore says she married one William Page, but, if that is true, they have not been found in 1860.

There is one William Page living in Fentress County in 1860, who was born c1837, so he is a good fit. However, he is married to Mary A. Abston, they have a two year old daughter and are living with her large family.

If this is the correct William Page, and I suspect it is because the Abstons are living right next door to the Riddle family in 1860, then Eliza died young and left no surviving children.

Jane Riddle was born c1839 in Fentress County, Tennessee and died after 1850. She is not at home in 1860 and no further record has been found for her.

There are two more children to cover in this family – daughters Happy and Elizabeth (Betty) Riddle, the ninth and tenth children of Isaac and Catherine Riddle.

Both had large families – Happy had thirteen children and Betty had ten so there are many details to be shared.

Friday’s Family History Finds

The best Family History Finds this week:

Family Stories

HELP NEEDED:
Can You Identify the People at Camp Edwards? by Jennifer Holik on Soul Traveler

Uncle Don, WWII Veteran AND My Faithful Veteran, both by Joy on Joy Neal Kidney

The Dramatic Life of Catherine Sloan (born c1760) by Jason Duncan on webjmd

One Old Swedish Letter Revealed a Forgotten Bridge Builder by Kirsten Max-Douglas on Our Growing Family Tree

Jeanne Chebrat (1627 – 1678/1686), The Miller’s Daughter – 52 Ancestors #489 by Roberta Estes on DNAeXplained – Genetic Genealogy

Cher Ami: America’s Most Honored Passenger: The Soldier Pigeon of WWI by Lori Olson White on The Lost & Found Story Box

Research Resources

Top Tips for Searching a Database of a Worldwide Obituaries Collection on Russian Immigrants by Vera Miller on Find Lost Russian & Ukrainian Family

Finding the Fallen: Online Archives for Remembrance Sunday: Tracing Scottish Service Personnel Records Part 2 by Chris on The Scottish Genealogist

Death Documents Abound – Consular Reports of Death Abroad by Kenneth R. Marks on The Ancestor Hunt

Tech News

Three Ways to Avoid CAPTCHA Prompts When Using a VPN by Ritoban Mukherjee on Lifehacker

Meet GAIA: MyHeritage’s New AI Genealogy Research Agent by Diane Henriks on Know Who Wears the Genes in Your Family

Hackers Now Want Your Browser Sessions More Than Your Passwords, but You Can Stop Them by Ritoban Mukherjee on Lifehacker

Taking a Look at Gaia by Natalie Webb on Family Tree Technology

Genetic Genealogy

A Segment Concept by Jim Bartlett on Segment-ology

Methodology

Uploaded Images to FamilySearch, FindAGrave, Ancestry, etc. by Michael John Neill on Genealogy Tip of the Day

Research at the Texas State Library & Archives: Finding the Muster Roll for Benjamin Cox and the Independent Blues by Diana elder on Family Locket

How I Document My Genealogy Research by Tina on A Little of This and That

Education Is for Everyone

“Applying Lessons Learned” When Researching Female Ancestors by Nancy Gilride Casey on Leaves on the Tree

Crayon Swindlers: The 1890s Photo Scam That Cost Families More Than Money by Maureen Taylor on The Photo Detective News

New Videos on Allen County Public Library’s YouTube Channel by Gail Dever on Genealogy a la Carte

Keeping Up with the Times

In honor of Veterans Day:
Veteran’s Day Transcription Project: Remembering Company E in Holton, Kansas by Marcia Crawford Philbrick on Heartland Genealogy

Missing from the Census? Or Are They?

Any researcher who says they’ve never, ever had any trouble finding anyone in any census record probably isn’t admitting the truth.

I’ve had a number of census brick walls through the years and, while it is possible – and probable – that a person or family was missed by the census taker, generally speaking, everyone we would expect can be accounted for in a given census enumeration.

Here are some of the issues that have confronted me through the years:

  1. Yes, the family changed their surname – unofficially and between censuses – from Kucharik to Sabo. I learned this from my grandmother after I started delving into the family history. I eventually would have found this out because it turns out Nana had my grandfather’s original baptismal certificate with the Kucharik surname on it. This happened in the early 1900s so if you have an immigrant family in that time period, check for other records verifying the family name. With technology help today, if any of the given names are unusual and you know where the family was living, that might also allow you to locate the family.
  2. Next, speaking about immigrant surnames, they were NOT changed at Castle Garden or Ellis Island. However, if the census taker had a difficult time understanding heavily accented English, it’s very possible that the family name was misspelled. This is exactly what happened with my Kuchariks. I still couldn’t find my great grandparents even after learning about the name change. I knew the neighborhood in Passaic, New Jersey where they would be living and I knew the family members, so I went page by page through that ward. I eventually found them. However, the census taker wrote down their name as RUHARIK with an R and no CH sound in the middle. They popped right up in the index when I looked for RUHARIK, which is not a spelling variation I would ever have thought of and wild card searches don’t work well with the first letter omitted.
  3. What if you find a family with the correct surname, but the given names are all wrong? Apparently, going by one’s middle name instead of first name became very “en vogue” in the 1870s. I was looking for my Coleman family which included children William E., Samuel J. and Thomas H. They all married and lived well into the 1900s. The children grew up in Calais, Maine, so I was puzzled when I couldn’t find them in 1880. However, I readily found Edgar W., Jones S. and Hartwell T. , who were the same ages as William, Samuel and Thomas. Not only did I learn their middle names from this change, but they liked their “new” names so well, they used them for the rest of their lives. Since two of the three moved away from Maine, knowing these names made tracking their lives much easier.
  4. While we are all thankful for neatly written census entries and correctly indexed records, the reality is very different and it doesn’t matter if indexing was done by a human or AI. Errors abound. The most egregious mistake I’ve come across was my search for Henry Nation, born c1814 in Ohio, but lived in Tennessee until 1850. He married several times and had at least nine children. I knew his third wife was Mary Riddle and they married c1848. However, Henry, Mary and children were nowhere to be found in Tennessee. I suspected they might have gone to Missouri, as some other extended family members had removed there. I tried all kinds of wild card searches with the Nation surname, but no success. Then, I decided to try a wild card search using “Henry,” born 1814, Ohio and living in Missouri. To my surprise, one Henry WATIAU appeared living in Crockett, Arkansas County, Arkansas. With him was (presumed) wife Mary and children. To be honest, the surname really reads as “Nathans,” but the N definitely looked like an N and not a W. This has since been updated and corrected on Ancestry and I suspect the indexing was done by a non-native English speaker who didn’t recognize the surname and misinterpreted the scrolly N for a W. Again, technology and wild cards will help work around spelling mistakes, but generally not well if the first letter is a wild card.
  5. Sometimes, we don’t even know that people are missing, but they are. That’s what happened with my 3X great grandmother, Rebecca (Jones) (Crouse) Blyther (1809-1897.) She was born in New Brunswick, Canada, married Peter Crouse there and had a small family. Peter died c1835. Rebecca married (2) Benjamin Blyther and moved to Red Beach, Maine. They had children together and Benjamin died in 1878 in Calais, Maine. I hadn’t really thought about it since Rebecca died in Maine and her gravestone is legible, but she wasn’t enumerated in 1880 in Calais. I thought since she had been widowed not long before, she might be visiting or living with family members in Canada. This was before Canadian censuses were readily available online. However, at one point, I did decide to trace all of my 2X great grandmother Sarah Moriah (Crouse) Coleman’s siblings and half sibling and that’s where the surprise appeared. In 1880, Rebecca was living with a daughter’s family in Cisco, Placer, CALIFORNIA! Not only that, but technology indexing advances brought up her death record – in Hubbardston, Worcester, MASSACHUSETTS! Therefore, I learned that at the age of about 70, Rebecca picked up and moved with her daughter across the country to California and then, at some point before she died, she traveled back to the East Coast and died in Massachusetts. I had no reason to suspect any of this as she is buried beside her husband in Red Beach, Washington, Maine. The lesson here is to follow collateral lines and check out some of the possibly strange hints that might come up on the big websites. A few might actually be accurate!
  6. Lastly, it is certain that some people were missed in some censuses. Official census dates were usually in April or June – prime moving time for families. Since enumerators were supposed to count everyone living in a certain house on the official day, you might think no one would be missed. However, what about if the enumerator just asked who was living in the house when he knocked on the door? One family might have moved out and another in. If families headed to the frontier, there probably weren’t even any houses for the census taker to visit! Even in the late 19th and early 20th century, immigrant families rented and moved often. What if the census taker arrived at their Home #1 the day after they moved out and another census taker knocked on the door of Home #2 a week before they moved in? Yep, they got missed.

One final tip. Of course, everyone dies in between censuses. However, absent a death certificate, family record, gravestone, will or probate, obituary, etc., DON’T assume that the person died. Children might be living with relatives or working on another farm. Widows might have remarried and, sometimes, like with Henry Nation, he upped and moved to another state and his name was wrongly indexed.

Cast a wide net, leaving no stone unturned. Be sure to follow all known children from birth to death and collateral sibling lines, too. You never know who will turn up in the house!