I am moving along through the Research Like a Pro with AI Genealogy Workbook and have reviewed Chapter 4, which is Using AI for Citations.
Again, I am definitely not a fan. I uploaded the 1850 census for Thomas Colman of Calais, Washington, Maine.

I queried Claude using the exact wording and template format as directed in the workbook. Claude was directed to leave blank information it didn’t know and to ask me about it.
This is the result:
Draft Citation:
1850 U.S. census, Manhattan County, Maine, population schedule, Solon, p. 2 (stamped), p. [need penned page number], dwelling [need dwelling number], family [need family number], Thomas Colman; image, “[need collection title],” [need website title] ([need URL]: accessed [need access date]).
Questions for you:
- What is the penned page number (handwritten at top)?
- What are the dwelling number (column 1) and family number (column 2) for Thomas Colman on line 26?
- What is the collection title (e.g., “NARA microfilm publication M432, roll ###”)?
- What website did you access this from (Ancestry, FamilySearch, etc.) and what is the URL?
- What is your access date?
I could have written a half dozen citations in the time I’ve spent on this and I’m not going to answer Claude’s questions and waste any more time.
the assignment was to create more source citations for sources in my timeline. Airtable was given as an example to gather sources, but the user would need a paid subscription.
Using AI to create citations – not for me!
I’m with you on this one! Citations only take me a few moments to create. This is one task I wouldn’t bother even consider moving to AI. The juice wouldn’t be worth the squeeze.
Plus, sourcing forces us to think about WHY we’re adding this information to our tree (or it should)…giving that over to AI is just a recipe for disaster.
DEFINITELY with you on this one. As you say, by the time you answered Claude’s questions in order to fill in the info it left blank, you could have written several more yourself! Just seems like a waste of time to me.
And yeah, Airtable not exactly an ideal platform for me either. Ancestral Sources is still my preferred way to craft my sources, followed by Cite-Builder. I do have the CB subscription, but much prefer giving money to a family company (we used to own one), than a large corporation. CB now has a feature for paid subscribers where it saves the citations you create.
Perhaps this is for people newer to genealogy who need help in writing citations. I agree with you all, that I’d have several written in the same time. I actually love writing citations so I would not let AI do this.